Title: The Famine Witch
Author: Stephen Black
Series or standalone: Standalone
Age Category: Adult
Published by: January 2024, Quill and Crow Publishing House
Pages: 282 p.
Genre: Historic fantasy
About The Famine Witch
Every 200 years the murders start in Belfast, 1847 the year they started again. Five girls have already disappeared, their bodies found with a Bloody Handprint to indicate the murderer. Bloody Hands is back and has been given a sixth victim that might be his undoing.
Multiple evils are attacking Belfast, the crops failed this year, and hunger is ravaging the town. Soon new evil docks ashore, one that brings disease. The Black Lady is coming for Belfast and will not stop until it is in ashes.
Within the chaos of hunger and disease, one girl and her brother try to survive one more day. Unbeknown to Maggie, she will be the only force against the evil in the town. All she wants though is for her brother to be safe.
My thoughts on The Famine Witch
Let me get the disclaimer out of the way. I was generously provided with a review copy of this book by Netgalley. This in no way influences my rating or thoughts about the book. Thanks, Netgalley, Quill and Crow Publishing, and Stephen Black for providing the ARC.
I picked this up because I was looking for newer Witchy books to highlight as a book of the month. Sometimes I wish I could read a bit faster so I could have done this review a bit earlier on, but I have now accepted that all things will come in the end, I will figure out how to balance my life I just need some more time to figure it all out.
What intrigued me about the synopsis was that it has a historical setting. I have never read anything set in Belfast, I also do not know much about its history. I love history, but sometimes forget how much I enjoy historical settings. History compared with the supernatural is something that works very well, especially in the 1800s. There was a lot of superstition in that time, about what causes disease and failing crops. I think this book plays into this aspect very nicely, it seems a very accurate depiction of how people would think about these things.
This story is told from multiple perspectives, we meet both bad guys of this story, Bloody Hands and Fionnuala the Black Lady. The focus from their perspectives was mainly on Fionnuala and then on Bloody Hands. I would have liked it, if there were more Bloody Hands chapters, it would have made the story even darker. I also feel that there is a lot about his story missing, for example, the reasoning behind his six victims, and what kind of creature he is. Why he slumbers for 200 years? None of these things are explained clearly. If he is a creature from Irish folklore that is famous in Northern Ireland then I might get that this is not explained, because an Irish audience probably grew up with the stories. However, if the author wants to appeal to a broader audience, that is not familiar with the mythology like me, then you will have to explain these things, to the audience.
In this book, I learned a lot of new words. English is my second language, I had to look up some of the words because they were terms that are not used in our language today. This is not a criticism of the book, not at all, I think the right terminology used, is important for the story, especially when you are writing historical fantasy. I also liked that there are Irish terms, however it was not easy to look them up, while I was reading. I would have liked to know that there was a Glossary of Terms in the back of the book, it was not indicated in the table of contents. I will state that this was an eARC so maybe this was resolved in the final copy. I thought I should mention it, in case they haven't fixed this.
Overall I thought it was a good depiction of the time and place, I love the balance between fantasy elements and history. I enjoyed all the characters in this book, also the religion of this book was not Catholic, they were mentioned but the story's religious sidestep is based on Protestant beliefs. This is a change from what you read in most witch trial-based books, I thought it was an interesting fact.
The Witchy rating of The Famine Witch
What is special about the Witchy Review is that I give an extra rating to the book, based on how Witchy the content is. This is a separate rating from the overall rating of the book. The rating given in this regard can be very different from the overall rating.
In this case, this will be so, as this book is plenty Witchy.
The historical setting gives this book witch trial vibes, there is a trial mentioned in the book, the trial of Fionnuala, which sets her on the path of revenge. There is also a scene where the Reverend Edgar riles up the town against Maggie.
Fortunately for Maggie, this does not end in a public execution, because she is under the protection of the Black Lady at this point. The story feels a bit rushed at this point, I would have loved for there to be more pages about Fionnuala and Maggie's powers. We get a little insight into Fionnuala's cruel power later on, but I will not spoil this part. It is the darkest part of the book I think, I loved it for it too.
This book gives all the Witchy vibes I would want out of a historical fantasy. The only remark I have on this is that I would have loved for it to have more spellwork in it. Other than that I think this is a very good read in read to all things Witchy. And let it be a reminder of all the women that have lost their lives, for helping others, or just for being a woman. 4 cauldron cats for Witchyness.
Overall rating of The Famine Witch
There are a couple of remarks I already made on the book, these are all minor things. There is one more thing that sometimes confused me and that the changing of the POVs was sometimes a bit unclear. Sometimes it took me a moment to find from which point of view I was reading and what the relevance of that person was regarding the story. There are a couple of chapters where we meet a random side character that was not introduced before.
In the beginning, this caused the pacing of the book to be very slow, which made the book more difficult to read. In the end, it all made sense, it could put people off to continue reading.
I did enjoy my time with this book, it is not perfect but besides the remarks I have it was still a good story in an interesting setting. Therefore the overall rating will be a little bit lower, and I will give it a 3-cat rating.
Comments